“Modern” homepage design increases pageviews and reader comprehension, study finds

suggestion box

News sites with modular, image-heavy designs receive more pageviews and have stronger user engagement than sites with more staid, newspaper-inspired designs, according to a report released Tuesday by the Engaging News Project.

Modern, modular homepages received at least 90 percent more unique pageviews than traditional sites did, the study found.

Users viewing the modular homepage recalled details of the articles at least 50 percent more often than did those who viewed the classic homepage, according to the report.

“The way in which you design your homepage can have a big effect,” said Talia Stroud, the director of the Engaging News Project and a professor at the University of Texas.

Stroud and her co-authors — Alex Curry, Arielle Cardona, and Cynthia Peacock — created two fictional news sites with 20 evergreen news stories selected from actual publications. They ran three different studies that involved 2,671 participants, and in each case the modern-looking site received more pageviews.

User reaction to the sites was similar across the surveyed demographics of age, education level, political knowledge, and familiarity with the design of the sites. In two out of the three studies, users found that the modern-looking site was more “enjoyable, informative, credible, trustworthy, interesting, clear, and easy to navigate.”

Classic site

In Study 1, 429 participants were required to stay on the site for 90 seconds before continuing with the study. The modern site received 813 unique pageviews, while the classic site received 427.

In the second and third studies, the researchers didn’t place any time restriction on how long users had to stay on the site. There were 405 participants in Study 2, and the contemporary site received 274 unique pageviews. The classic site had 93. In Study 3, the contemporary site attracted 254 unique pageviews from 332 users, compared to 105 for the traditional site.

“There are engaging pictures, and it’s a little bit more of an engaging layout,” Stroud said to explain why the contemporary site was better trafficked. “People aren’t as familiar with it, they find it interesting, they want to see how it works.”

Users also retained more information from stories presented on the contemporary homepage. They were asked to write down all the details they could remember from a handful of the stories on each site. In Study 1, viewers of the modern-looking site recalled 0.61 details, on average, from the stories, while classic site viewers recalled 0.37 details. In Study 2, users who saw the modern site remembered 0.43 details, compared to 0.18 details on average for those who saw the traditional site. The difference in the third study wasn’t statistically significant.

Conversely, when looking just at the homepage, users remembered more details on the classic homepage because that layout displayed the ledes from each story on the homepage. On the contemporary site, users had to scroll over the image to get the lede. The differences weren’t large, though, and the report “suggests that the learning implication of making the lede appear only when scrolling over the headline is minimal.”

In the third study, the researchers created a modified version of the classic site, in which articles expanded over the homepage once they were clicked instead of opening a new page. Between the classic and modified classic sites, there were no significant differences in how users clicked on stories, retained information, or perceived the sites. Users, however, still preferred the contemporary site to the modified classic site.

“It had the technical features of the contemporary site, but the look of the classic site to see if it was the technical features or the look and the layout [that made a difference],” Stroud said. “The result of that study showed it’s the look and the layout. It’s not the technical features.”

Despite the report’s findings, Stroud was quick to point out that the results were from mock news sites in a lab setting, not actual sites. Moving forward, Stroud said she’d like to work with a real news site throughout its redesign process to study how user behavior changes.

“It would be a dream if there was a news organization…that’s doing some sort of a homepage redesign and would be interested in collaborating with us beforehand to test it, and then have them roll it out and see if what we’re able to do in a lab, or online experiment setting, replicates with what happens when they actually launch the site,” Stroud said. “I think that would be really important and so helpful to news organizations.”

Ultimately though, Stroud emphasized, that news organizations would stand to benefit from studying user behavior as part of their redesign processes. The report’s authors highlighted The Guardian, The New York Times, and The Daily Beast as outlets that successfully explained recent design changes to their users and incorporated user feedback into their redesigns.

“What this research adds is a starting point for how one might redesign a news homepage and a research method that could help to reveal whether a redesign will have a desired effect,” the report’s authors wrote.

Via: News

Newsonomics: The halving of America’s daily newsrooms

Thumbnail for 2735

Cigar maker. Elevator operator. Pinsetter. Iceman. Lamplighter. Switchboard operator. Local daily newspaper reporter? How soon will we have to add this once-stable occupation to the list of jobs that once were — occupations once numerous that … [Continue reading]

So a hacker brought down your news site. Now what? New York magazine found out today

So let's say you're a New York–based publication which has just published the words and portraits of 35 women who have accused Bill Cosby of rape — on your cover no less. Then a hacker decides to launch an all-out distributed denial of … [Continue reading]

Gimlet wants to become the “HBO of podcasting” — here’s what its founder’s learned trying to get there

Thumbnail for 2730

Last summer, radio reporter Alex Blumberg made a decision that, by his own admission, was “crazy.” Blumberg — known for his work with Planet Money, which he co-founded with economics journalist Adam Davidson,This American Life, and … [Continue reading]

Can Campbell Brown’s education news site walk the advocacy–journalism tightrope?

Thumbnail for 2728

The newcomer to education news outlets has a not-so-new name attached to it: Campbell Brown, veteran television reporter and former CNN and NBC News anchor, who has in recent years taken on the role of education reform advocate. So far, her … [Continue reading]

Trouble in paradise? How the struggles of two Hawaiian paywalls reflect larger industry trends

Thumbnail for 2726

It was billed as the Pugnacious Polynesian Paywall Punch-Up. RELATED ARTICLEHawaiian punch! A paywall showdown in HonoluluAugust 8, 2011Honolulu Civil Beat, a local news site backed by eBay founder Pierre Omidyar, launched in 2010 with an ad-free … [Continue reading]

Citing “an inflection point in global media,” Pearson sells the Financial Times to Nikkei

Thumbnail for 2724

RELATED ARTICLENewsonomics: How much is the Financial Times worth, and who might buy it?July 22, 2015“What the FT really needed was to be part of an organization absolutely focused on journalism,” Pearson CEO John Fallon told reporters in … [Continue reading]

One of the best things a news startup can do for its financial health: Hire a professional ad person

A new report from the Tow-Knight Center for Entrepreneurial Journalism, out Thursday, interviewed 22 digital publishers, most of which launched in the last 10 years, to determine best practices for “building ad revenue at local news and niche … [Continue reading]

“People like a website without advertising”: The thinking behind a newspaper’s ad-free membership

RELATED ARTICLEThe Salt Lake Tribune, its future uncertain, offers to eliminate all its ads — for 10 bucks a monthJuly 21, 2015Yesterday we wrote about The Salt Lake Tribune's new membership program, but even after that post went live, we had … [Continue reading]

Why don’t The New York Times (and other news organizations) link out to sources more often?

Like many other news organizations, The New York Times wrote about the recent high-profile resignations at Gawker (here's the link), and like a few others, it chose not to link to the root of the Gawker upheaval, a story about a male escort's … [Continue reading]

Powered by WP Robot